Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jewish ethnocentrism/Logs

Add links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Log Record[edit]

This is a clarification for the record. This is a copy what administrators see, and is posted here for public view. -- AllyUnion (talk) 19:38, 14 Feb 2005 (UTC)

  • All times listed below are according to my own timezone, which is Pacific Standard Time, -(0800) from UTC. -- AllyUnion (talk) 19:43, 14 Feb 2005 (UTC)
  • Except those marked with (UTC) as indicated by the automatic timestamp. -- AllyUnion (talk) 20:25, 14 Feb 2005 (UTC)
Excerpt from Protection Log[edit]
  • 12:11, 13 Feb 2005 Jnc unprotected Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/Jewish ethnocentrism/previous (Well, there's no point protecting this then)
  • 12:09, 13 Feb 2005 AndyL protected Jewish ethnocentrism (recreaed after VFD)
  • 12:02, 13 Feb 2005 AndyL protected Jewish ethnocentrism (VFD succeeded to delete)
  • 11:54, 13 Feb 2005 AndyL protected Jewish ethnocentrism (attempts to recreate page deleted by VfD)
  • 11:37, 13 Feb 2005 Mikkalai unprotected Jewish ethnocentrism (protected with violation of rules: by atricle's editor)
  • 11:35, 13 Feb 2005 Jnc protected Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/Jewish ethnocentrism/previous (Prevent vandalism by people who keep re-creating the page)
  • 11:30, 13 Feb 2005 Jnc protected Jewish ethnocentrism (Deleted per vote on VfD, people keep re-creating it, blanking, protecting)

View and restore deleted pages[edit]

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.

If you restore the page, all revisions will be restored to the history by default. If you do not want to restore all revisions, select only the checkboxes by the revisions you do want to restore. If a new page with the same name has been created since the deletion, the restored revisions will appear in the prior history, and the current revision of the live page will not be automatically replaced.

Deletion log[edit]

  • 12:06, 13 Feb 2005 Mikkalai deleted Jewish ethnocentrism (content was: '{{protected}}')
  • 12:04, 13 Feb 2005 Mikkalai restored "Jewish ethnocentrism"
  • 12:04, 13 Feb 2005 Curps deleted Jewish ethnocentrism (deleted as per VfD and VfU consensus.)
  • 11:58, 13 Feb 2005 Mikkalai restored "Jewish ethnocentrism"
  • 11:58, 13 Feb 2005 Mikkalai restored "Jewish ethnocentrism"
  • 11:55, 13 Feb 2005 AndyL deleted Jewish ethnocentrism
  • 11:52, 13 Feb 2005 AndyL deleted Jewish ethnocentrism (A VFD has decided to delete this already.)
  • 07:27, 13 Feb 2005 Snowspinner deleted Jewish ethnocentrism (Consensus was to delete article, not redirect it.)
  • 22:11, 12 Feb 2005 Rdsmith4 deleted Jewish ethnocentrism (recreated after being deleted by VFD vote)
  • 12:51, 6 Feb 2005 AndyL deleted Jewish Ethnocentrism (content was: '#REDIRECT Jewish ethnocentrism')
  • 12:49, 6 Feb 2005 AndyL deleted Jewish ethnocentrism (content was: '#REDIRECT ethnocentrism')
  • 12:42, 6 Feb 2005 AndyL deleted Jewish ethnocentrism (VfD and attempt to stack vote by Stormfront.)

Page history[edit]

  • 12:05, 13 Feb 2005 . . AndyL ()
  • 12:03, 13 Feb 2005 . . AndyL ()
  • 11:59, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai (blanking and deleting of an article ith new content is violation of policies)
  • 11:54, 13 Feb 2005 . . AndyL ()
  • 11:53, 13 Feb 2005 . . AndyL ()
  • 11:40, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai (restore. removal of a VfD is a violation of wikipedia policy)
  • 11:38, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mel Etitis ()
  • 11:37, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai (rv. This is a *new* article. Protecting an article by an editor is still another violation of policy.)
  • 11:34, 13 Feb 2005 . . Jnc (Reblank)
  • 11:30, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai (this is not re-creation. This is a totally different article, about the existing term)
  • 11:29, 13 Feb 2005 . . Jnc (Article was deleted per vote on VfD. Stop re-creating it.)
  • 11:25, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai (Reverted edits by Mel Etitis to last version by Mikkalai)
  • 11:23, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mel Etitis ()
  • 11:21, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai ()
  • 11:20, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai ()
  • 11:19, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai ()
  • 11:18, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai (you are blatantly violating deletion policy guys.)
  • 11:16, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mel Etitis (rv to last correct version)
  • 11:12, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai (content moved to talk. You violated the policy of speedy deletions.)
  • 11:10, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai ()
  • 11:10, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai ()
  • 11:09, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai ()
  • 11:08, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai ()
  • 10:51, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mel Etitis (deleted content, and added message)
  • 10:31, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai ()
  • 05:55, 13 Feb 2005 . . BM (Redirect to Ethnocentrism. See comments on Talk page.)
  • 01:44, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai (Reverted edits by Silsor to last version by Rdsmith4)
  • 01:37, 13 Feb 2005 . . Silsor (#REDIRECT Ethnocentrism)
  • 22:17, 12 Feb 2005 . . Rdsmith4 (never mind - I deleted this, but it turns out it's just a redirect)
  • 21:52, 12 Feb 2005 . . SlimVirgin (Is this title supposed to exist?)
  • 21:23, 12 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai ()
  • 12:48, 6 Feb 2005 . . AndyL ()
  • 07:37, 5 Feb 2005 . . Slrubenstein (see talk)
  • 07:34, 5 Feb 2005 . . Slrubenstein (Reverted edits by Acidmonkey to last version by 128.120.185.31)
  • 01:50, 5 Feb 2005 . . Acidmonkey ()
  • 18:56, 4 Feb 2005 . . 128.120.185.31 (I provided something to balance out the bile in this article, athough I still say it should be deleted.)
  • 10:52, 4 Feb 2005 . . Slrubenstein (References - don't put text in bibliography, only references.)
  • 10:49, 4 Feb 2005 . . Slrubenstein (Reverted edits by Xed to last version by 66.31.7.30)
  • 10:29, 4 Feb 2005 . . Xed (rv to preferred version, see talk)
  • 19:20, 3 Feb 2005 . . 66.31.7.30 ()
  • 16:59, 3 Feb 2005 . . Guy Montag (This reads like a diatribe from a neo nazi.)
  • 15:24, 3 Feb 2005 . . Slrubenstein (Reverted edits by Xed to last version by Slrubenstein)
  • 14:59, 3 Feb 2005 . . Xed ()
  • 12:18, 3 Feb 2005 . . Slrubenstein ()
  • 12:17, 3 Feb 2005 . . Slrubenstein (Possible reasons and justifications for Jewish ethnocentrism)
  • 12:17, 3 Feb 2005 . . Slrubenstein (Exclusivism)
  • 12:17, 3 Feb 2005 . . Slrubenstein (Examples)
  • 05:59, 3 Feb 2005 . . Sam Spade (rv, at least merge the two, tehre is plenty of good content here)
  • 18:03, 2 Feb 2005 . . Yoshiah ap (Jewish Ethnocentrism)
  • 17:19, 2 Feb 2005 . . Xed (rv to more neutral version)
  • 10:40, 2 Feb 2005 . . SlimVirgin (see talk)
  • 10:22, 2 Feb 2005 . . Slrubenstein (see talk)
  • 10:20, 2 Feb 2005 . . Slrubenstein (Exclusivism - deleting material that has nothing to do with ethnocentrism)
  • 10:16, 2 Feb 2005 . . Slrubenstein (Examples - removing cases that are not examples of ethnocentrism)
  • 14:31, 1 Feb 2005 . . SlimVirgin (remove sources tag)
  • 14:19, 1 Feb 2005 . . Sam Spade (rv, thats no way to edit an article, esp. one your newly involved with)
  • 12:29, 1 Feb 2005 . . BM ()
  • 12:26, 1 Feb 2005 . . BM ()
  • 11:07, 1 Feb 2005 . . Xed (notices)
  • 11:04, 1 Feb 2005 . . Xed (rv to more neutral version)
  • 21:22, 31 Jan 2005 . . Jpgordon (Anti-semites who can't spell anti-semitic. Always cute.)
  • 10:04, 31 Jan 2005 . . Jayjg (Cleanup. Ethnic, not racial. As for particularly targetting Muslims and "other Arabs", says who?)
  • 09:41, 31 Jan 2005 . . Slrubenstein (Reverted edit of Sam Spade, changed back to last version by Slrubenstein)
  • 09:41, 31 Jan 2005 . . Sam Spade (Ethnic diversity within Judaism - ==Semitism==)
  • 09:40, 31 Jan 2005 . . Sam Spade (replacing deleted text)
  • 08:50, 31 Jan 2005 . . Slrubenstein (Semitism)
  • 08:49, 31 Jan 2005 . . Slrubenstein (Possible reasons and justifications for Jewish ethnocentrism - deleting irrelevant section)
  • 08:45, 31 Jan 2005 . . Slrubenstein (Exclusivism - deleting section that is not about ethnocentrism)
  • 08:44, 31 Jan 2005 . . Slrubenstein (Examples - deleting material that doesn't bear on the topic)
  • 06:30, 31 Jan 2005 . . ZayZayEM ("their own kind" just sounds off putting)
  • 04:44, 31 Jan 2005 . . Zero0000 (Ethnic diversity within Judaism - what's a thousand years between friends?)
  • 03:00, 31 Jan 2005 . . Sam Spade (See also - *Particularism)
  • 02:59, 31 Jan 2005 . . Sam Spade (References - victim blaming)
  • 02:58, 31 Jan 2005 . . Sam Spade (These views may include hate propaganda directed toward other cultures, particularly Muslims, and other Arabs.)
  • 02:52, 31 Jan 2005 . . Sam Spade (Semitism)
  • 02:47, 31 Jan 2005 . . Sam Spade (Counter-arguments)
  • 02:42, 31 Jan 2005 . . Sam Spade (Kevin B. MacDonald)
  • 02:42, 31 Jan 2005 . . Sam Spade (Kevin B. MacDonald)
  • 02:41, 31 Jan 2005 . . Sam Spade (Possible reasons and justifications for Jewish ethnocentrism)
  • 02:37, 31 Jan 2005 . . Sam Spade (Exclusivism - Jews as a chosen people, - uncited POV's)
  • 02:30, 31 Jan 2005 . . Sam Spade (fmt, wl)
  • 02:27, 31 Jan 2005 . . Sam Spade (Kevin B. MacDonald - competition)
  • 02:27, 31 Jan 2005 . . Sam Spade (Kevin B. MacDonald's theory - various)
  • 02:24, 31 Jan 2005 . . Sam Spade (intro)
  • 02:09, 31 Jan 2005 . . Sam Spade (restore content)
  • 02:03, 31 Jan 2005 . . Sam Spade (references)
  • 02:00, 31 Jan 2005 . . Sam Spade (references)
  • 00:58, 31 Jan 2005 . . SlimVirgin ()
  • 08:07, 30 Jan 2005 . . Jayjg (rv: the MacDonald theories are given at length in the article devoted to them, we don't want to duplicate all that, or have this page only about MacDonald. That should be obvious.)
  • 06:37, 30 Jan 2005 . . Sam Spade (rv, don't delete the majority of the page, that should be obvious)
  • 23:20, 29 Jan 2005 . . SlimVirgin (fixed typo)
  • 23:19, 29 Jan 2005 . . SlimVirgin (deleted most of MacDonald's theories, and most unreferenced or irrelevant claims)
  • 07:49, 29 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (High average IQ test scores)
  • 07:32, 29 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (High average IQ test scores)
  • 07:23, 29 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (High average IQ tests scores)
  • 07:21, 29 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (High ethnocentrism and selective breeding not needed to explain high average Ashkenazi IQ -Added that environment can also explain iq gap)
  • 06:57, 29 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (John Tooby - Removed unsupported view)
  • 19:48, 28 Jan 2005 . . Wareware (See also)
  • 11:18, 28 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (High average IQ - No need for selective breeding)
  • 10:21, 28 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (High average IQ - More complete)
  • 10:11, 28 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (Added High average IQ)
  • 08:51, 28 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (Research on ingroup bias)
  • 08:48, 28 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (Research on ingroup bias)
  • 08:05, 28 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (Research on ingroup bias)
  • 07:59, 28 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (Counter-arguments - Research on ingroup bias)
  • 06:31, 28 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (John Tooby - Quote)
  • 06:01, 28 Jan 2005 . . Sam Spade (John Tooby - you seem to be trying to quote Judith Shulevitz, not tooby, but it doesn't matter, since its not in quotations anyways)
  • 05:58, 28 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine ()
  • 05:55, 28 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (Moved holocaust concentration to bias in historical research)
  • 05:43, 28 Jan 2005 . . 213.89.160.137 (John Tooby - Changed to what Tooby actually stated)
  • 05:32, 28 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (Moved items in introduction to better sections)
  • 05:23, 28 Jan 2005 . . Sam Spade (John Tooby - repair of section)
  • 05:17, 28 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (Alleged, not proven)
  • 05:14, 28 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (Counter-arguments -Created new paragraph from earlier material)
  • 05:04, 28 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (Possible reasons and justifications for Jewish ethnocentrism - Changed content and title to be a presentation of MacDonald's theory)
  • 04:04, 28 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (John Tooby - Changed to actual quote and removed possible original research)
  • 02:28, 28 Jan 2005 . . SlimVirgin ()
  • 02:24, 28 Jan 2005 . . Sam Spade (Alleged examples of Jewish ethnocentrism - -alleged)
  • 01:46, 28 Jan 2005 . . SlimVirgin (Deleted Macdonald rebuttal as original research and also because much of his stuff has been moved)
  • 01:40, 28 Jan 2005 . . SlimVirgin (Edit conflict. Redid Willmcw's edit.)
  • 01:36, 28 Jan 2005 . . SlimVirgin (Made "anecdotal evidence" section invisible because of weblog as source. See Talk)
  • 01:32, 28 Jan 2005 . . Willmcw (+link to new article, deletion of MacDonald material)
  • 01:01, 28 Jan 2005 . . Willmcw (undo revert = a lot of work has been done on these edits.)
  • 00:50, 28 Jan 2005 . . Jacquerie27 (Reverting.)
  • 23:54, 26 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (Anecdotal evidence - Added peer-review)
  • 23:48, 26 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (Anecdotal evidence)
  • 23:45, 26 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (Anecdotal evidence - Clearer critque)
  • 19:45, 26 Jan 2005 . . Jayjg (MacDonald's theory - this article is supposed to be about Jewish ethnocentrism, not about people who have theories about group evolutionary strategies)
  • 19:07, 26 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (Attachment in infants)
  • 16:18, 26 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (Counter-arguments -Added Influence of Jews on public opinion)
  • 15:53, 26 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (Support - Changed to more correct title)
  • 15:07, 26 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (Counter-arguments -Removing some duplicate arguments)
  • 14:08, 26 Jan 2005 . . SlimVirgin (MacDonald's theory - deleted scholarly)
  • 14:04, 26 Jan 2005 . . Slrubenstein (MacDonald's theory - took out peer-review, made clear its not an academic press)
  • 13:20, 26 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (MacDonald's theory - No peer-review)
  • 07:02, 26 Jan 2005 . . Ultramarine (Moved theory from Kevin B. MacDonald here to avoid duplication. Needs editing :).)
  • 08:01, 17 Jan 2005 . . Jayjg (Possible reasons and justifications for Jewish ethnocentrism -Who has made this argument? Sources please.)
  • 11:23, 16 Jan 2005 . . SlimVirgin (removed 1st sentence of 2nd para because it had no reference and was unclear)
  • 18:31, 15 Jan 2005 . . SlimVirgin ()
  • 18:30, 15 Jan 2005 . . SlimVirgin (more tweaks)
  • 18:23, 15 Jan 2005 . . SlimVirgin (typo)
  • 18:23, 15 Jan 2005 . . SlimVirgin (more copy editing)
  • 18:04, 15 Jan 2005 . . SlimVirgin (tweak)
  • 17:59, 15 Jan 2005 . . SlimVirgin (copy edit; this article illustrates well why Wikipedia's strength is its weakness.)
  • 13:02, 14 Jan 2005 . . Slrubenstein (Examples claimed to support the theory - it is not a "theory")
  • 08:18, 14 Jan 2005 . . Jayjg (Possible reasons and justifications for Jewish ethnocentrism -well, this was definitely POV. Awaiting comment on the Talk: page for other un-supported claims)
  • 02:58, 14 Jan 2005 . . Zantastik (critical reaction in context)
  • 02:53, 14 Jan 2005 . . Zantastik (getting attacked in slate isn't going to help his popularity)
  • 16:34, 9 Jan 2005 . . SlimVirgin (Jewish Attitudes to Jewish and non-Jewish suffering - deleted Cohen passage)
  • 14:31, 9 Jan 2005 . . Jacquerie27 (Is this better?)
  • 10:20, 9 Jan 2005 . . SlimVirgin (pasted a comment here instead of on Talk (!); sorry, have removed it)
  • 07:35, 9 Jan 2005 . . SlimVirgin ()
  • 16:30, 8 Jan 2005 . . Jayjg (Reverted edits by 213.178.224.227 to last version by Jayjg)
  • 04:24, 8 Jan 2005 . . 213.178.224.227 (Ethnic diversity within Judaism)
  • 08:35, 7 Jan 2005 . . Jayjg (Reverted edits by 213.178.224.227 to last version by Jayjg)
  • 08:05, 7 Jan 2005 . . 213.178.224.227 (Ethnic diversity within Judaism)
  • 08:00, 7 Jan 2005 . . 213.178.224.227 (Ethnic diversity within Judaism)
  • 15:07, 5 Jan 2005 . . Jayjg (Ethnic diversity within Judaism - Judaism is universalist too)
  • 15:03, 5 Jan 2005 . . Jayjg (Jewish attitudes to conversion -hmm, exclusivism?)
  • 14:30, 5 Jan 2005 . . Jacquerie27 (Adding link to Chinese ethnocentrism.)
  • 14:29, 5 Jan 2005 . . Jacquerie27 (Genetic diversity and conversion.)
  • 10:30, 5 Jan 2005 . . Jayjg (Ethnic diversity within Judaism)
  • 06:57, 5 Jan 2005 . . 213.178.224.227 (Ethnic diversity within Judaism)
  • 06:53, 5 Jan 2005 . . 213.178.224.227 (Ethnic diversity within Judaism)
  • 06:50, 5 Jan 2005 . . 213.178.224.227 (Ethnic diversity within Judaism)
  • 06:47, 5 Jan 2005 . . 213.178.224.227 (Ethnic diversity within Judaism)
  • 13:59, 3 Jan 2005 . . Jacquerie27 (Jewish importance; attitudes to Jewish and non-Jewish suffering; ethnic diversity within Judaism.)
  • 12:15, 3 Jan 2005 . . Slrubenstein (Reverted edits by Willmcw to last version by Slrubenstein)
  • 11:57, 3 Jan 2005 . . Willmcw (Terminology - Central is a good word for a -centric movement)
  • 10:13, 3 Jan 2005 . . Slrubenstein (Reverted edits by Jacquerie27 to last version by Jayjg)
  • 14:51, 2 Jan 2005 . . Jacquerie27 (Rmvg POV "disproportional".)
  • 14:41, 2 Jan 2005 . . Jayjg (Terminology - sp)
  • 13:57, 2 Jan 2005 . . Willmcw (Terminology - delete graf about what some say)
  • 16:14, 1 Jan 2005 . . Willmcw (attempt to improve the terminology section)
  • 15:41, 1 Jan 2005 . . Jacquerie27 (Typo.)
  • 15:38, 1 Jan 2005 . . Willmcw (Use of the concept and term by anti-Semites - copyedit)
  • 15:36, 1 Jan 2005 . . Willmcw (correct reference to usage of term - mostly used by anti-semitic groups.)
  • 15:15, 1 Jan 2005 . . Jacquerie27 (Reductio ad Hitlerum.)
  • 15:13, 1 Jan 2005 . . Jacquerie27 (Definition of the term, Yaacov Perrin, etc.)
  • 09:42, 1 Jan 2005 . . Slrubenstein (Reverted edits by Jacquerie27 to last version by Jayjg)
  • 04:32, 1 Jan 2005 . . Jacquerie27 (Reductio ad Hitlerum.)
  • 07:11, 31 Dec 2004 . . Jacquerie27 (Definition of the term, Yaacov Perrin, etc.)
  • 14:58, 28 Dec 2004 . . Jayjg (Possible reasons and justifications - re-direct)
  • 11:24, 28 Dec 2004 . . Jayjg (Jewish ethnocentrism - rm blank line)
  • 11:23, 28 Dec 2004 . . Jayjg (Examples claimed to support the theory - rv Alberuni sockpuppet)
  • 10:14, 28 Dec 2004 . . RomperRoomReject (rv ListenToThis)
  • 09:47, 28 Dec 2004 . . Olve (Examples of Jewish ethnocentrism - Examples from a society's extreme right are not representative of the society in general unless the extreme right has very wide support...)
  • 09:34, 28 Dec 2004 . . Olve (Jewish ethnocentrism - Anti-"Gypsy" prejudice not specifically or predominantly Jewish.)
  • 05:00, 28 Dec 2004 . . ListenToThis (Examples of Jewish ethnocentrism - doesn't ring a bell)
  • 21:54, 27 Dec 2004 . . RomperRoomReject (add)
  • 15:17, 27 Dec 2004 . . Willmcw (Examples of Jewish ethnocentrism - delete unnecessary heading)
  • 15:07, 27 Dec 2004 . . ListenToThis (Examples of Jewish ethnocentrism)
  • 15:00, 27 Dec 2004 . . RomperRoomReject (rv)
  • 13:47, 27 Dec 2004 . . ListenToThis (Examples of Jewish ethnocentrism - never heard of em)
  • 09:06, 27 Dec 2004 . . RomperRoomReject (Rabbis are learned Jews)
  • 08:47, 27 Dec 2004 . . Jayjg (Examples of Jewish ethnocentrism - removing non-notable quote. Who was Perrin again?)
  • 06:31, 27 Dec 2004 . . Jacquerie27 (Retrieving famous ethnocentric quote from the memory hole.)
  • 19:43, 26 Dec 2004 . . Jayjg (Examples of Jewish ethnocentrism - link)
  • 19:40, 26 Dec 2004 . . Jayjg (Examples of Jewish ethnocentrism - no clear link to Bible influence)
  • 16:42, 26 Dec 2004 . . Willmcw (Possible Biblical justification - changed section name, which has nothing to do with Bible)
  • 16:35, 26 Dec 2004 . . Jayjg (Possible Biblical justification - non Bibilical quote by non-notable person - has anyone ever heard of Perrin outside this one quote?)
  • 15:21, 26 Dec 2004 . . Jfdwolff (dablink, fmt, uniform use of case in titles)
  • 13:35, 26 Dec 2004 . . AndyL (POV, moved to talk. You shouldn't be putting forward an argument in the article)
  • 13:16, 26 Dec 2004 . . Jacquerie27 (References.)
  • 11:40, 26 Dec 2004 . . AndyL (Original research. Who are these "opponents"? Where do thay make these arguments?)
  • 11:25, 26 Dec 2004 . . Jacquerie27 (Ethnic diversity of Judaism.)
  • 15:30, 25 Dec 2004 . . AndyL (googling "jewish ethnocentrism" returns its use on sites such as the "vanguard news network")
  • 15:30, 25 Dec 2004 . . AndyL (googling "jewish ethnocentrism" returns its use on sites such as the "vanguard news network")
  • 12:31, 25 Dec 2004 . . Slrubenstein (Possible Biblical Justification for Jewish Ethnocentrism - deleting an example that is not an example of ethnocentrism)
  • 09:38, 23 Dec 2004 . . AndyL (Counter Arguments)
  • 03:06, 23 Dec 2004 . . IZAK ({{Jew}})
  • 15:37, 22 Dec 2004 . . AndyL (Counter Arguments)
  • 12:28, 19 Dec 2004 . . Jayjg (Counter Arguments - This is incorrect; a mamzer is the result of an adulterous or incestuous relationship, not the result of an out of wedlock union)
  • 07:06, 19 Dec 2004 . . AndyL (qualification)
  • 06:53, 19 Dec 2004 . . Jacquerie27 (Mamzerim.)
  • 05:18, 17 Dec 2004 . . AndyL (a) pov b) response to rape does militate)
  • 02:19, 17 Dec 2004 . . Jacquerie27 (Counter-arguments -- rape by outsiders is not sought by a particular group etc.)
  • 06:01, 15 Dec 2004 . . AndyL (Counter Arguments)
  • 05:58, 15 Dec 2004 . . AndyL (This isn't true - Judaism is matralineal, ie all that matters is whether or not your mother is Jewish regardless of the faith of your father.)
  • 05:52, 15 Dec 2004 . . AndyL (Counter Arguments)
  • 05:41, 15 Dec 2004 . . AndyL (Counter Arguments)
  • 01:30, 15 Dec 2004 . . Jacquerie27 (Counter arguments.)
  • 11:41, 12 Dec 2004 . . Jacquerie27 (mitigate > militate, taxes on Jews.)
  • 11:35, 12 Dec 2004 . . AndyL (Counter Arguments)
  • 11:25, 12 Dec 2004 . . Jacquerie27 (Tidying etc.)
  • 11:07, 12 Dec 2004 . . AndyL (for one thing, claim that Jews would no longer exist if they had intermarried is a theory, not a fact)
  • 11:06, 12 Dec 2004 . . AndyL (for one thing, claim that Jews would no longer exist if they had intermarried is a theory, not a fact)
  • 10:27, 12 Dec 2004 . . Jacquerie27 (Restoring section.)
  • 07:37, 12 Dec 2004 . . AndyL (Rm pov statements. MacDonald's theory is not a fact and should not be treated as such. Please rewrite.)
  • 04:00, 12 Dec 2004 . . Jacquerie27 (Expanding.)
  • 02:32, 11 Dec 2004 . . Jacquerie27 (Scientific approaches to alleged Jewish ethnocentrism (top).)
  • 02:31, 11 Dec 2004 . . Jacquerie27 (Scientific approaches to alleged Jewish ethnocentrism.)
  • 17:48, 13 Aug 2004 . . Kate (External links corrections; see User:Kate/extlinks)
  • 16:33, 13 Jul 2004 . . Guanabot (Guanaco - Robot bypassing redirects: Zionist)
  • 17:13, 12 Jul 2004 . . Guanabot (Guanaco - Robot bypassing redirects: Jewish)
  • 21:57, 5 Jul 2004 . . Stevertigo ()
  • 21:56, 5 Jul 2004 . . Stevertigo (External Link)
  • 05:51, 13 Jun 2004 . . IZAK (Category:Anti-Semitism)
  • 09:25, 1 Mar 2004 . . Alex S (Link to Jews as a Chosen people)
  • 15:46, 25 Jan 2004 . . Snoyes (Reverted to last edit by MyRedDice)
  • 15:43, 25 Jan 2004 . . 66.2.156.84 ()
  • 13:19, 22 Oct 2003 . . MyRedDice (mainstream -> more mainstream)
  • 10:24, 22 Oct 2003 . . Slrubenstein ()
  • 05:12, 22 Oct 2003 . . 193.60.79.152 ()
  • 05:34, 5 Oct 2003 . . MyRedDice (add para on chosenness (see Talk))
  • 10:06, 7 Aug 2003 . . MyRedDice (lk Jewish view of marriage - a fantastic article)
  • 10:00, 7 Aug 2003 . . MyRedDice (See also: Jewish views of religious pluralism, chosen people (see Talk))
  • 13:00, 29 Jul 2003 . . MyRedDice (*, -"s")
  • 12:59, 29 Jul 2003 . . MyRedDice (rm dup link to Zionism)
  • 02:16, 21 May 2003 . . MyRedDice (re semitism)
  • 06:53, 14 May 2003 . . MyRedDice (reinstating alternative spelling - see talk:semitism)
  • 06:48, 14 May 2003 . . Danny (removed dubious alternative spelling. )
  • 05:26, 14 May 2003 . . MyRedDice (Shemitism - alternate spelling of the word "Semitism")
  • 10:59, 16 Mar 2003 . . MyRedDice (aka "Semitism" (cf SOED))
  • 10:49, 16 Mar 2003 . . TUF-KAT ()
  • 15:52, 12 Mar 2003 . . RK ()
  • 08:03, 12 Mar 2003 . . Danny ()
  • 08:02, 12 Mar 2003 . . Danny (there is actually an article on Porajmos)
  • 07:48, 12 Mar 2003 . . MyRedDice (Jewish ethnicity redirects to "Jew", removing ; also give Ian Hancock as an example)
  • 07:33, 12 Mar 2003 . . MyRedDice ("all other" -> "other")
  • 07:03, 12 Mar 2003 . . Ed Poor (article still sucks, though)
  • 07:01, 12 Mar 2003 . . Ed Poor (copy-edit)
  • 07:01, 12 Mar 2003 . . Ed Poor (more POV attribution: Zionism = ethnocentrism)
  • 13:02, 1 Mar 2003 . . Slrubenstein (deleted section on chosenness, a concept which is not judeocentric)
  • 16:15, 23 Feb 2003 . . RK (Pointing out that much of Reform still does accep the idea of choseness (that was one of the hallmarks of Classic German Reform; the mission to the gentiles))
  • 16:01, 23 Feb 2003 . . Danny (and that's how misquotes get started ... )
  • 15:58, 23 Feb 2003 . . MyRedDice (name branches of Judaism which are chosen people, per Danny's Talk)
  • 09:52, 23 Feb 2003 . . Danny (at least 2 out of the four reject chosenness explicitly. the other two play around with its definition--see talk)
  • 09:50, 23 Feb 2003 . . Danny (everybody holds that their beliefs are correct. )
  • 08:55, 23 Feb 2003 . . MyRedDice (put back in a fact that we actually have some agreement on in Talk)
  • 08:53, 23 Feb 2003 . . MyRedDice (define as "an alleged belief that Jewish cultural traditions and values are correct and superior to all others")
  • 08:43, 23 Feb 2003 . . The Cunctator (Discussion of Jewish ethnicity belongs there, not at Jewish ethnocentrism)
  • 08:36, 23 Feb 2003 . . The Cunctator (Compressing "chosen people" paragraph.)
  • 08:35, 23 Feb 2003 . . The Cunctator (Ethnocentrism is defined in its own entry. It should not be defined here.)
  • 08:29, 23 Feb 2003 . . DanKeshet (even->including)
  • 13:37, 22 Feb 2003 . . Jennifer (intermarriage statistics are controversial)
  • 08:33, 22 Feb 2003 . . MyRedDice (restoring text on religious pluralism, plus header)
  • 08:30, 22 Feb 2003 . . MyRedDice (another go at the intro, based on Talk)
  • 07:29, 22 Feb 2003 . . MyRedDice (how about this intro, RK?)
  • 06:45, 22 Feb 2003 . . RK (Removing the introduction, which was an anti-Semitic lie. sin't anyone here bothered by the non-stop Jew bashing?)
  • 02:21, 22 Feb 2003 . . Ducker (Grrrrr... stupid single quote)
  • 22:21, 21 Feb 2003 . . Jennifer (Reverted The Cunctator's contribution (see talk))
  • 22:13, 21 Feb 2003 . . The Cunctator ()
  • 22:04, 21 Feb 2003 . . The Cunctator (Refactoring.)
  • 21:06, 21 Feb 2003 . . Koyaanis Qatsi (reverting to 14:24 Feb 21, 2003 state and freezing for the night)
  • 20:53, 21 Feb 2003 . . Danny (Reverted to last edit by Stevertigo)
  • 20:39, 21 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (better to add than to remove information. if you see a POV, fix it.)
  • 20:15, 21 Feb 2003 . . Stevertigo (Ignorance is not a valid POV - the knife that is your intellect need sharpening - I recommend less khakis and more school...)
  • 20:11, 21 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (facts aren't POV. hiding facts is. if you want NPOV, point to specific facts as being wrong. don't write whitewash)
  • 20:07, 21 Feb 2003 . . Stevertigo (That was not a merging of material at all... your writing style .....lacks NPOV)
  • 20:03, 21 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (finished incorporating everything; instead of reverting, work forward from this)
  • 20:01, 21 Feb 2003 . . Stevertigo (Jeezus Clutch, youre obsessed.... get a grip... get out of the house, if you can...)
  • 19:57, 21 Feb 2003 . . Clutch ()
  • 19:47, 21 Feb 2003 . . Stevertigo ()
  • 19:46, 21 Feb 2003 . . Clutch ()
  • 19:43, 21 Feb 2003 . . Stevertigo (tai po)
  • 19:41, 21 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (sp. prejudice)
  • 19:40, 21 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (moving paragraph on the Holocaust towards beginning of article; other cleanups)
  • 19:39, 21 Feb 2003 . . Stevertigo (tia po)
  • 19:38, 21 Feb 2003 . . Stevertigo (blah... without the inuendo... "evolution" Clutch?)
  • 19:30, 21 Feb 2003 . . Danny (bolded title.)
  • 19:26, 21 Feb 2003 . . Stevertigo (Restoring a basic lead - Deleting suspect POV by Clutch)
  • 19:10, 21 Feb 2003 . . Danny ()
  • 18:56, 21 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (editing last two paragraphs; fixing section heading)
  • 18:49, 21 Feb 2003 . . MyRedDice (modifying clutch's version, since he asked me to work with him)
  • 18:46, 21 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (restoring NPOV)
  • 18:44, 21 Feb 2003 . . MyRedDice (rm link to Supersessionism, which is probably relevant to *christian* ethnocentrism, but not Jewish ethnocentrism)
  • 18:28, 21 Feb 2003 . . Danny (Reverted to last edit by 128.193.88.101)
  • 18:22, 21 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (restoring NPOV)
  • 17:44, 21 Feb 2003 . . 128.193.88.101 (reverting)
  • 17:35, 21 Feb 2003 . . Clutch ()
  • 17:25, 21 Feb 2003 . . Stevertigo (removed a couple paragraphs at the bottom - I want to see source on that.... )
  • 17:17, 21 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (adding back in the information that was deleted)
  • 17:09, 21 Feb 2003 . . 128.193.88.101 (reverting clutch's drivel)
  • 17:05, 21 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (adding info about Holocaust industry)
  • 17:02, 21 Feb 2003 . . Ducker (glitchy siongle-quote)
  • 16:49, 21 Feb 2003 . . 128.193.88.101 (making article more encyclopedic)
  • 16:47, 21 Feb 2003 . . Clutch ()
  • 16:43, 21 Feb 2003 . . 128.193.88.101 (bling-bling)
  • 16:36, 21 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (adding in information relevant to the topic; it's no good if it limits itself to a dictionary definition)
  • 16:33, 21 Feb 2003 . . MyRedDice (revert - It's not clear how an article that doesn't mention the palestinians can slur them in a racist manner)
  • 16:32, 21 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (removing racist smearing of Palestinians)
  • 16:31, 21 Feb 2003 . . MyRedDice (editing 2nd para - remove reference to Arab-Israeli conflict - the article is controversial enough already...)
  • 16:27, 21 Feb 2003 . . 128.193.88.101 (CLUTCH U WUD BE FUN33 14 U W3R3 N0T L4M3!!!)
  • 16:25, 21 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (Please work forward from this. This one attempts to be neutral. The other is a racist Zionist smear on Palestinians)
  • 16:24, 21 Feb 2003 . . MyRedDice (Is Judaism judeocentric? Yes and no...)
  • 16:21, 21 Feb 2003 . . 128.193.88.101 (ha-ha clutch you are a funny guy)
  • 16:17, 21 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (Martin, work forward from this. This one attempts to be neutral. The other is a racist Zionist smear on Palestinians)
  • 16:16, 21 Feb 2003 . . 128.193.88.202 (book isn't relevant without the mossad information in the article, add both or remove both)
  • 16:08, 21 Feb 2003 . . MyRedDice (revert Clutch. Also, reference the Mossad book Cluch likes, which seems relevant here)
  • 16:06, 21 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (making article more encyclopedic)
  • 16:04, 21 Feb 2003 . . MyRedDice (rm "The term is not exactly defined, nor its validity generally accepted" - see Talk)
  • 15:52, 21 Feb 2003 . . 128.193.88.202 (REVERTING ASSMONKEYISMS)
  • 15:46, 21 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (making article more encyclopedic and informative)
  • 06:24, 21 Feb 2003 . . MyRedDice (format)
  • 06:23, 21 Feb 2003 . . MyRedDice (add google search)
  • 06:17, 21 Feb 2003 . . MyRedDice (copy+paste defn of ethnocentrism from ethnocentrism)
  • 06:08, 21 Feb 2003 . . RK ()
  • 06:08, 21 Feb 2003 . . RK (See also: Ethnocentrism, Chosen people)
  • 06:06, 21 Feb 2003 . . MyRedDice ("highest state" to "ideal state")
  • 06:06, 21 Feb 2003 . . MyRedDice (summary plus link of Jewish view of marriage - check for accuracy, please)
  • 05:43, 21 Feb 2003 . . RK (Restoring the article that Clutch dishonestly deleted. This article still sucks. See the Talk page. And Sysops, please ban Clutch. He *still* is vandalizing this article every few hours.)
  • 19:16, 20 Feb 2003 . . Ericd ()
  • 18:19, 20 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (One should address the issues raised, instead of pretending they don't exist)
  • 18:09, 20 Feb 2003 . . RK (The original content was removed by Clutch, and replaced with an anti-Semitic rant. Please do not help him. He is a vandal.)
  • 18:08, 20 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (if it is ok to delete this article, it must be ok to delete the "Christian anti-Semitism" and "Islamic anti-Semitism" articles too, right?)
  • 18:02, 20 Feb 2003 . . Ericd (deleting article content is pure junk)
  • 17:56, 20 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (tweaking last paragraph)
  • 17:52, 20 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (Putting back Jimmy Wales revision)
  • 17:41, 20 Feb 2003 . . RK (Deleting Clutch's rants about the Jews.)
  • 17:29, 20 Feb 2003 . . Clutch ()
  • 17:27, 20 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (No whitewashing; reincorporating Jimmy Whales edits)
  • 16:34, 20 Feb 2003 . . 128.193.88.236 (is this more NPOV?)
  • 16:23, 20 Feb 2003 . . Jimbo Wales (Softening too-bold claim(s) - this article still sucks)
  • 16:18, 20 Feb 2003 . . Jimbo Wales (Reverted to last edit by 128.193.88.236)
  • 14:01, 20 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (anonymous IP's edit labelled "better grammar" actually didn't change grammar at all; it did change the sense of a certain statement dramatically)
  • 13:56, 20 Feb 2003 . . 128.193.88.236 ()
  • 13:28, 20 Feb 2003 . . Clutch ()
  • 13:27, 20 Feb 2003 . . 128.193.88.236 (better grammar)
  • 12:26, 20 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (rewording a paragraph for NPOV; "fact" => "tendency")
  • 12:25, 20 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (I encourage RK to work the WikiWay, and not just delete the entire contents of articles he doesn't like)
  • 12:24, 20 Feb 2003 . . RK (VANDALISM ALERT. Clutch is STILL filling Wikipedia with anti-Semitic rants. Why do Wikipedia Sysops refuse to ban him? Please, stop this insanity.)
  • 12:22, 20 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (compaign => campaign)
  • 12:20, 20 Feb 2003 . . RK ()
  • 12:19, 20 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (intermarry with => marry)
  • 12:18, 20 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (regardless of => without reference to)
  • 12:18, 20 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (Reverting a white-wash attempt by an anonymous IP)
  • 12:10, 20 Feb 2003 . . 62.30.150.99 ()
  • 12:09, 20 Feb 2003 . . Snoyes (_actually_ make more neutral (in general I also don't really like this entry - but we should work within the wikipedia system rather than just calling something vandalism <gets off soapbox>))
  • 12:07, 20 Feb 2003 . . Clutch ()
  • 12:04, 20 Feb 2003 . . Clutch ()
  • 11:46, 20 Feb 2003 . . Clutch ()
  • 11:39, 20 Feb 2003 . . Wesley (copyedits and links)
  • 11:33, 20 Feb 2003 . . Clutch ()
  • 11:30, 20 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (more npov work)
  • 11:13, 20 Feb 2003 . . 129.240.152.21 (fixed a couple of links. Blargh. someone help npov it a bit more.)
  • 11:12, 20 Feb 2003 . . 129.240.152.21 (tried to npov it a bit. Probably not successful. )
  • 09:30, 20 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (RK is deleting a valid article instead of working on it. If any of the facts in it are wrong, let someone be honest and refute them. Trying to whitewash the truth is not what the Wikipedia is for)
  • 09:27, 20 Feb 2003 . . RK (VANDALISM ALERT. Clutch is STILL filling Wikipedia with anti-Semitic rants. Why do Wikipedia Sysops refuse to ban him? Please, stop this insanity.)
  • 09:25, 20 Feb 2003 . . Clutch ()
  • 09:24, 20 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (people => citizens)
  • 09:23, 20 Feb 2003 . . Clutch ()
  • 09:23, 20 Feb 2003 . . RK (Reverting Clutch's vandalism. VANDALISM ALERT. Please ban Clutch; he is a vandal.)
  • 09:22, 20 Feb 2003 . . Clutch ()
  • 09:20, 20 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (making a general statement more specific)
  • 09:20, 20 Feb 2003 . . Clutch (just the facts; this article touches on a real issue. RK's previous biased version pretended Judeocentrism doesn't even exist!)
  • 09:13, 20 Feb 2003 . . RK (Deletinc Clutch's anti-Semitic rants. Request to Sysops to delete this article. It has only been used for Jew-bashing. What does this tell you?)
  • 08:57, 20 Feb 2003 . . Clutch ()
  • 16:58, 18 Feb 2003 . . Jennifer (attempt at NPOV stub)
  • 15:44, 8 Feb 2003 . . Slrubenstein (see talk)
  • 15:43, 8 Feb 2003 . . Martha ()
  • 10:15, 7 Feb 2003 . . RK (Deleted article. Its sole purpose was to incite anti-Semitism. Wikipedia is not the appropriate forum for anti-Semites to obsess about Jews.)
  • 09:59, 7 Feb 2003 . . Slrubenstein ()
  • 09:58, 7 Feb 2003 . . Slrubenstein ()
  • 00:10, 7 Feb 2003 . . ShameOnTerrorists ()
  • 20:37, 6 Feb 2003 . . Stevertigo (removing anti-Semitic gabage. "vandalism... vandalism...")
  • 20:35, 6 Feb 2003 . . ShameOnTerrorists ()
  • 20:35, 6 Feb 2003 . . Stevertigo (removing anti-Semitic nonsense.)
  • 20:34, 6 Feb 2003 . . ShameOnTerrorists ()
  • 20:29, 6 Feb 2003 . . Danny (removed nonsense)
  • 20:28, 6 Feb 2003 . . Stevertigo (Resurrecting my "bias" Judeocentrism in the Judeocentrism article!.. go figure...)
  • 20:22, 6 Feb 2003 . . ShameOnTerrorists (erasing biased view)
  • 20:18, 6 Feb 2003 . . Stevertigo (stubble growth...)
  • 20:17, 6 Feb 2003 . . Stevertigo ()
  • 20:17, 6 Feb 2003 . . Stevertigo (stubble.)

Clarification of actions according to edits and log[edit]

1st deletion[edit]
  • 12:42, 6 Feb 2005 AndyL deleted Jewish ethnocentrism (VfD and attempt to stack vote by Stormfront.)
After deletion[edit]
  • 12:48, 6 Feb 2005 . . AndyL ()

Now, what happened here was that AndyL deleted the article per VfD then recreated it with the following text: 

  1. REDIRECT ethnocentrism
2nd deletion[edit]
  • 12:49, 6 Feb 2005 AndyL deleted Jewish ethnocentrism (content was: '#REDIRECT ethnocentrism')

AndyL then apparently deleted the article again.

Deletion at Jewish Ethnocentrism[edit]
  • 12:51, 6 Feb 2005 AndyL deleted Jewish Ethnocentrism (content was: '#REDIRECT Jewish ethnocentrism')

AndyL then deleted an article with the same title, except with the minor capitalization in the E in Ethnocentrism. That page was created by Sam Spade at 10:52, 28 Dec 2004.

3rd deletion[edit]
  • 22:11, 12 Feb 2005 Rdsmith4 deleted Jewish ethnocentrism (recreated after being deleted by VFD vote)

Rdsmith4 deleted the article.

Prior to deletion[edit]
  • 21:23, 12 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai ()

Mikkalai recreated the article as a redirect: 

  1. redirect Culture of Critique
  • 21:52, 12 Feb 2005 . . SlimVirgin (Is this title supposed to exist?)

It was then blanked out by SlimVirgin.

4th deletion[edit]

Alright. Now, the next deletion was at:

  • 07:27, 13 Feb 2005 Snowspinner deleted Jewish ethnocentrism (Consensus was to delete article, not redirect it.)
Prior to deletion[edit]
  • 22:17, 12 Feb 2005 . . Rdsmith4 (never mind - I deleted this, but it turns out it's just a redirect)

Rdsmith4 restored Mikkalai's version, as can be seen by the edit: 

  1. REDIRECT Culture of Critique

These are the next three edits:

  1. 01:37, 13 Feb 2005 . . Silsor (#REDIRECT Ethnocentrism)
  2. 01:44, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai (Reverted edits by Silsor to last version by Rdsmith4)
  3. 05:55, 13 Feb 2005 . . BM (Redirect to Ethnocentrism. See comments on Talk page.)


As clearly spelled out by the three experienced users, Silsor changed Mikkalai's version to a redirect to Ethnocentrism. Mikkalai then reverted it. Then BM reverted Mikkalai's version.

5th deletion[edit]
  • 11:52, 13 Feb 2005 AndyL deleted Jewish ethnocentrism (A VFD has decided to delete this already.)
Prior to deletion[edit]
  • 10:31, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai ()
  1. redirect Culture of Critique
  • 10:51, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mel Etitis (deleted content, and added message)

(This page, both content and title, was deleted after a formal VfD debate and vote, and a motion for its undeletion was debated and almost unanimously defeated. It's not wanted on Wikipedia. Once it has been deleted again by an admin., please don't recreate it.) Mel Etitis (Μελ Ετητης) 18:51, 13 Feb 2005 (UTC)

  • 11:08, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai ()

(This page, both content and title, was deleted after a formal VfD debate and vote, and a motion for its undeletion was debated and almost unanimously defeated. It's not wanted on Wikipedia. Once it has been deleted again by an admin., please don't recreate it.) Mel Etitis (Μελ Ετητης) 18:51, 13 Feb 2005 (UTC)

This deletion by an admin is a violation of wikipedia policy of speedy deletions. Quoting: Reposted content that was deleted according to Wikipedia deletion policy. The aricle with different content was deleted. Please follow the normal procedure, i.e., vote. Mikkalai 19:08, 13 Feb 2005 (UTC)
  • 11:09, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai ()

(This page, both content and title, was deleted after a formal VfD debate and vote, and a motion for its undeletion was debated and almost unanimously defeated. It's not wanted on Wikipedia. Once it has been deleted again by an admin., please don't recreate it.) Mel Etitis (Μελ Ετητης) 18:51, 13 Feb 2005 (UTC)

This deletion by an admin is a violation of wikipedia policy of speedy deletions. Quoting: Reposted content that was deleted according to Wikipedia deletion policy. The aricle with different content was deleted. Please follow the normal procedure, i.e., vote. Mikkalai 19:08, 13 Feb 2005 (UTC)
  • 11:10, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai ()

(This page, both content and title, was deleted after a formal VfD debate and vote, and a motion for its undeletion was debated and almost unanimously defeated. It's not wanted on Wikipedia. Once it has been deleted again by an admin., please don't recreate it.) Mel Etitis (Μελ Ετητης) 18:51, 13 Feb 2005 (UTC)

This deletion by an admin is a violation of wikipedia policy of speedy deletions. Quoting from the list of cases: Reposted content that was deleted according to Wikipedia deletion policy. The aricle with different content was deleted. Please follow the normal procedure, i.e., vote. Mikkalai 19:08, 13 Feb 2005 (UTC)
  • 11:10, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai ()

(This page, both content and title, was deleted after a formal VfD debate and vote, and a motion for its undeletion was debated and almost unanimously defeated. It's not wanted on Wikipedia. Once it has been deleted again by an admin., please don't recreate it.) Mel Etitis (Μελ Ετητης) 18:51, 13 Feb 2005 (UTC)

This deletion by an admin is a violation of wikipedia policy of speedy deletions. Quoting from the list of valid cases: Reposted content that was deleted according to Wikipedia deletion policy. The aricle with different content was deleted. Please follow the normal procedure, i.e., vote. Mikkalai 19:08, 13 Feb 2005 (UTC)
  • 11:12, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai (content moved to talk. You violated the policy of speedy deletions.)
  1. redirect Culture of critique
  • 11:16, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mel Etitis (rv to last correct version)

(This page, both content and title, was deleted after a formal VfD debate and vote, and a motion for its undeletion was debated and almost unanimously defeated. It's not wanted on Wikipedia. Once it has been deleted again by an admin., please don't recreate it.) Mel Etitis (Μελ Ετητης) 18:51, 13 Feb 2005 (UTC)

  • 11:18, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai (you are blatantly violating deletion policy guys.)

Jewish etnhocentrism is a particular case of ethnocentrism. Some authors, notably Kevin B. MacDonald in his Culture of critique claims that Jewish ethnocentrism played a significant role in survival of Jews as distinct people.

See also

  • 11:19, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai ()

Jewish etnhocentrism is a particular case of ethnocentrism. Some authors, notably Kevin B. MacDonald in his Culture of critique, claim that Jewish ethnocentrism played a significant role in survival of Jews as distinct people.

See also

  • 11:20, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai ()

{{vfd}} Jewish etnhocentrism is a particular case of ethnocentrism. Some authors, notably Kevin B. MacDonald in his Culture of critique, claim that Jewish ethnocentrism played a significant role in survival of Jews as distinct people.

See also

  • 11:21, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai ()

{{subst:vfd}} Jewish etnhocentrism is a particular case of ethnocentrism. Some authors, notably Kevin B. MacDonald in his Culture of critique, claim that Jewish ethnocentrism played a significant role in survival of Jews as distinct people.

See also

  • 11:23, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mel Etitis ()

{{subst:vfd}}

  • 11:25, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai (Reverted edits by Mel Etitis to last version by Mikkalai)

{{subst:vfd}} Jewish etnhocentrism is a particular case of ethnocentrism. Some authors, notably Kevin B. MacDonald in his Culture of critique, claim that Jewish ethnocentrism played a significant role in survival of Jews as distinct people.

See also

  • 11:29, 13 Feb 2005 . . Jnc (Article was deleted per vote on VfD. Stop re-creating it.)

Protection log reference:

  • 11:30, 13 Feb 2005 Jnc protected Jewish ethnocentrism (Deleted per vote on VfD, people keep re-creating it, blanking, protecting)
  • 11:30, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai (this is not re-creation. This is a totally different article, about the existing term)

{{subst:vfd}} Jewish etnhocentrism is a particular case of ethnocentrism. Some authors, notably Kevin B. MacDonald in his Culture of critique, claim that Jewish ethnocentrism played a significant role in survival of Jews as distinct people.

See also

  • 11:34, 13 Feb 2005 . . Jnc (Reblank)

Protection log reference:

  • 11:35, 13 Feb 2005 Jnc protected Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/Jewish ethnocentrism/previous (Prevent vandalism by people who keep re-creating the page)

Protection log reference:

  • 11:37, 13 Feb 2005 Mikkalai unprotected Jewish ethnocentrism (protected with violation of rules: by atricle's editor)
  • 11:37, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai (rv. This is a *new* article. Protecting an article by an editor is still another violation of policy.)

{{subst:vfd}} Jewish etnhocentrism is a particular case of ethnocentrism. Some authors, notably Kevin B. MacDonald in his Culture of critique, claim that Jewish ethnocentrism played a significant role in survival of Jews as distinct people.

See also

  • 11:38, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mel Etitis ()

The content of the article was deleted according to Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/Jewish ethnocentrism/previous.

  • 11:40, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai (restore. removal of a VfD is a violation of wikipedia policy)

{{subst:vfd}} Jewish etnhocentrism is a particular case of ethnocentrism. Some authors, notably Kevin B. MacDonald in his Culture of critique, claim that Jewish ethnocentrism played a significant role in survival of Jews as distinct people.

See also

6th deletion and beyond[edit]

The clarification from this point will be log interjections and content posts.

  • 11:53, 13 Feb 2005 . . AndyL ()

test

  • 11:54, 13 Feb 2005 . . AndyL ()

Protection log reference:

  • 11:54, 13 Feb 2005 AndyL protected Jewish ethnocentrism (attempts to recreate page deleted by VfD)

Deletion log reference:

  • 11:55, 13 Feb 2005 AndyL deleted Jewish ethnocentrism

Deletion log reference:

  • 11:58, 13 Feb 2005 Mikkalai restored "Jewish ethnocentrism"

Deletion log reference:

  • 11:58, 13 Feb 2005 Mikkalai restored "Jewish ethnocentrism"
  • 11:59, 13 Feb 2005 . . Mikkalai (blanking and deleting of an article ith new content is violation of policies)

{{subst:vfd}} Jewish etnhocentrism is a particular case of ethnocentrism. Some authors, notably Kevin B. MacDonald in his Culture of critique, claim that Jewish ethnocentrism played a significant role in survival of Jews as distinct people.

See also

Protection log reference:

  • 12:02, 13 Feb 2005 AndyL protected Jewish ethnocentrism (VFD succeeded to delete)
  • 12:03, 13 Feb 2005 . . AndyL ()

Category:Deleted pages

Deletion log reference:

  • 12:04, 13 Feb 2005 Curps deleted Jewish ethnocentrism (deleted as per VfD and VfU consensus.)

Deletion log reference:

  • 12:04, 13 Feb 2005 Mikkalai restored "Jewish ethnocentrism"
  • 12:05, 13 Feb 2005 . . AndyL ()

{{protected}}

Deletion log reference:

  • 12:06, 13 Feb 2005 Mikkalai deleted Jewish ethnocentrism (content was: '{{protected}}')

From Edit History:

  • (cur) (last) 12:09, 13 Feb 2005 AndyL

Protection log reference:

  • 12:09, 13 Feb 2005 AndyL protected Jewish ethnocentrism (recreaed after VFD)

Protection log reference:

  • 12:11, 13 Feb 2005 Jnc unprotected Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/Jewish ethnocentrism/previous (Well, there's no point protecting this then)
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Jewish_ethnocentrism/Logs&oldid=357531836"